About HIPJ
HIPJ History
HIPJ Homepage
HIPJ FAQ
Weblog Archives

Search



Featured Posts
Iraq War WMD Case
Peak Oil Primer

Alternative News
Democracy Now
Z Magazine
Indypendent Magazine
Indymedia(US)
Indymedia(UK)
Counterpunch
Corporation Watch

US News
NY Times
Wall Street Journal
Washington Post
Washington Times
Boston Globe
LA Times
ABC News
CBS News
MSNBC
Fox News
CSPAN
CNN
Reuters

World News
BBC (UK) News
The Independent (UK)
The Guardian (UK)
The Hindu(India)
The Indian Express
The Dawn(Pakistan)
Globe and Mail (Canada)
Ha'aretz(Israel)
Jerusalem Post
Le Monde(France)
Mail and Guardian(South Africa)
Moscow Times (Russia)
Christian Science Monitor
United Press International
Colombia Times

Magazines/ Journals
The Economist
Foreign Affairs
Foreign Policy
Business Week
News Week
Time Magazine
The Atlantic Monthly
Harpers
The New Republic
Outlook India
Frontline (India)

Harvard Publications
The Crimson
The Harvard Independent
The Harvard College Economist
Harvard Focus Europe
Diversity and Distinction
Flare
Harvard International Review
Harvard Perspective

Harvard Organizations
Harvard Friends of Amnesty International
Harvard Living Wage Campaign
Harvard Students Against Sweatshops

Archives By Category
Africa
Blog Notes
Cuba
HIPJ Meetings
Imperialism
India/Pakistan
Iran
Iraq
Israel/Palestine
Latin America
Mainstream Media
Militarism
Misc
Oil and Energy
Russia
Student Activism
United States
Video
Vietnam


Last 20 Posts
Former HIPJ Member and Democracy Now Producer Arrested at Republican National Convention
Georgia, Russia, Gas, Oil and Kosovo
Stephen Kinzer: America's Century of Regime Change
The Bush Administration's WMD Case for the Iraq War: Intelligence Sought to Justify a Decision Already Made
Naomi Klein Article: China's All-Seeing Eye
Seymour Hersh: U.S. Funding Covert Operations in Iran
New York Times Op-Ed: The Two Israels
Proposed US - Iraqi Alliance/ Status of Forces Agreement
KSG Article: "Playing Favorites on Dictators Robs U.S. of High Ground"
A Foreboding Day in History
Peak Oil Primer
Bush's Appeasement Speech in Israel & Recent History with Iran
Imperial Life in the Emerald City
Pangea Day
Lie by Lie: The Mother Jones Iraq War Timeline
McCain Implies Energy Guides U.S. Involvement in the Middle East
Kissinger's New Domino Theory
Cyclone Nargis in Myanmar
Harvard SDS Iraq War Die In
Letter from Jose Ramos-Horta

Recent Comments


www.iraqbodycount.org


Note: Iraq body count only uses media reported, corroborated casualty figures. The number above therefore represents a lower bound on the number of deaths. Other estimates are shown here





Stephen Kinzer: America's Century of Regime Change

Former New York Times Reporter Stephen Kinzer has written several books about regime change as a tool of US foreign policy. In 1982 he co-wrote Bitter Fruit: The Story of the American Coup in Guatemala and has written two more recent books All the Shah's Men: An American Coup and the Roots of Middle East Terror (2003) about the US engineered coup against Mossadegh in Iran in 1953 and Overthrow: America's Century of Regime Change from Hawaii to Iraq (2006), an omnibus history of 14 US engineered overthrows of foreign governments starting in 1893. There are several talks available online where Kinzer talks about Overthrow and All the Shahs men. Here is a talk from Fora.tv where he discusses Overthrow:


The 14 interventions Kinzer discusses in Overthrow are:
  1. 1893: The overthrow of the Hawaiian monarchy.
  2. 1898: Spanish-American War - Takeover of Cuba.
  3. 1898: Spanish-American War - Takeover of Puerto Rico.
  4. 1898: Spanish-American War - Takeover of the Philippines.
  5. 1910: Installation of General Estrada in Nicaragua.
  6. 1912: Installation of President Bonilla in Honduras.
  7. 1953: Coup against Mossadegh in Iran.
  8. 1954: Overthrow of Arbenz in Guatemala.
  9. 1963: Coup against Diem in South Vietnam.
  10. 1973: Coup against Allende in Chile.
  11. 1983: Invasion of Grenada.
  12. 1989: Invasion of Panama.
  13. 2001: Invasion of Afghanistan.
  14. 2003: Invasion of Iraq.
Kinzer also has two interviews on Democracy Now for each of his two latest books, two about Iran and All the Shahs Men and two about Overthrow. Here is an excerpt from the first of the Democracy Now Overthrow interviews regarding the standard pattern that Kinzer sees in the development of these interventions:
You ask about the motivations, and that is one of the patterns that comes through when you look at these things all together. There's really a three-stage motivation that I can see when I watch so many of the developments of these coups. The first thing that happens is that the regime in question starts bothering some American company. They start demanding that the company pay taxes or that it observe labor laws or environmental laws. Sometimes that company is nationalized or is somehow required to sell some of its land or its assets. So the first thing that happens is that an American or a foreign corporation is active in another country, and the government of that country starts to restrict it in some way or give it some trouble, restrict its ability to operate freely.

Then, the leaders of that company come to the political leadership of the United States to complain about the regime in that country. In the political process, in the White House, the motivation morphs a little bit. The U.S. government does not intervene directly to defend the rights of a company, but they transform the motivation from an economic one into a political or geo-strategic one. They make the assumption that any regime that would bother an American company or harass an American company must be anti-American, repressive, dictatorial, and probably the tool of some foreign power or interest that wants to undermine the United States. So the motivation transforms from an economic to a political one, although the actual basis for it never changes.

Then, it morphs one more time when the U.S. leaders have to explain the motivation for this operation to the American people. Then they do not use either the economic or the political motivation usually, but they portray these interventions as liberation operations, just a chance to free a poor oppressed nation from the brutality of a regime that we assume is a dictatorship, because what other kind of a regime would be bothering an American company?
Kinzer's books are worth reading and his interviews worth listening to.


Posted July 15, 2008 | Comments? (0)

Leave a comment