About HIPJ
HIPJ History
HIPJ Homepage
HIPJ FAQ
Weblog Archives

Search



Featured Posts
Iraq War WMD Case
Peak Oil Primer

Alternative News
Democracy Now
Z Magazine
Indypendent Magazine
Indymedia(US)
Indymedia(UK)
Counterpunch
Corporation Watch

US News
NY Times
Wall Street Journal
Washington Post
Washington Times
Boston Globe
LA Times
ABC News
CBS News
MSNBC
Fox News
CSPAN
CNN
Reuters

World News
BBC (UK) News
The Independent (UK)
The Guardian (UK)
The Hindu(India)
The Indian Express
The Dawn(Pakistan)
Globe and Mail (Canada)
Ha'aretz(Israel)
Jerusalem Post
Le Monde(France)
Mail and Guardian(South Africa)
Moscow Times (Russia)
Christian Science Monitor
United Press International
Colombia Times

Magazines/ Journals
The Economist
Foreign Affairs
Foreign Policy
Business Week
News Week
Time Magazine
The Atlantic Monthly
Harpers
The New Republic
Outlook India
Frontline (India)

Harvard Publications
The Crimson
The Harvard Independent
The Harvard College Economist
Harvard Focus Europe
Diversity and Distinction
Flare
Harvard International Review
Harvard Perspective

Harvard Organizations
Harvard Friends of Amnesty International
Harvard Living Wage Campaign
Harvard Students Against Sweatshops

Archives By Category
Africa
Blog Notes
Cuba
HIPJ Meetings
Imperialism
India/Pakistan
Iran
Iraq
Israel/Palestine
Latin America
Mainstream Media
Militarism
Misc
Oil and Energy
Russia
Student Activism
United States
Video
Vietnam


Last 20 Posts
Former HIPJ Member and Democracy Now Producer Arrested at Republican National Convention
Georgia, Russia, Gas, Oil and Kosovo
Stephen Kinzer: America's Century of Regime Change
The Bush Administration's WMD Case for the Iraq War: Intelligence Sought to Justify a Decision Already Made
Naomi Klein Article: China's All-Seeing Eye
Seymour Hersh: U.S. Funding Covert Operations in Iran
New York Times Op-Ed: The Two Israels
Proposed US - Iraqi Alliance/ Status of Forces Agreement
KSG Article: "Playing Favorites on Dictators Robs U.S. of High Ground"
A Foreboding Day in History
Peak Oil Primer
Bush's Appeasement Speech in Israel & Recent History with Iran
Imperial Life in the Emerald City
Pangea Day
Lie by Lie: The Mother Jones Iraq War Timeline
McCain Implies Energy Guides U.S. Involvement in the Middle East
Kissinger's New Domino Theory
Cyclone Nargis in Myanmar
Harvard SDS Iraq War Die In
Letter from Jose Ramos-Horta

Recent Comments


www.iraqbodycount.org


Note: Iraq body count only uses media reported, corroborated casualty figures. The number above therefore represents a lower bound on the number of deaths. Other estimates are shown here





Why is this not racism?

Wesley Clark wrote an op-ed for the Crimson. In this op-ed, Clark says:
".... and today, more than 400 brave men and women have paid the price."

later, in the article:
"we need to change course. We need a president who does more than talk about success. We need a president with a plan to achieve it. I do not just say this; I have done it. In the war in Kosovo we achieved our goals without the loss of a single American soldier"

So, when Clark thinks of the consequences of the war, he sees only American troops, not the devastation of an entire country and thousands of people killed or maimed by the invasion. And, he is proud of Kosovo because the aims were achieved without American casualties. What about Yugoslavian casualties?

This selfish, ethnocentric attitude is precisely what allowed this war to happen. When will people like Clark, Bush and Clinton acknowledge that other parts of the world are inhabited by human beings. These human beings have a culture and political structures and a history -- that the 'Arab mind' cannot be understood, because there is no 'Arab mind'.

As far as the human consequences of the war go, body counts mean nothing because it is impossible to quantify the devastation caused by the war. Tabulating casualties is disgusting and voyeuristic. But, if we are ever foced into doing so, we must keep the following principles in mind:

1. Either, count only Iraqi civilians
2. If American troops are counted, Iraqi troops must be counted. About 30,000 of them perished.

Any sentence that begins with "400 American troops and 10,000 Iraqi civilians" is racist, whether or not the author of the statement is aware of the deeply offensive assumptions inherent in the sentence structure.

P.S: When I re-read what I wrote above, I realise how angry I was when I wrote it! But, anyway Trygve tells me that, at Kirkland House today, Wesley Clark supported 'The Israeli Wall'. Among his many reasons, one was : "Palestinians and other terrorists should not be allowed to enter Israel".



Posted December 08, 2003 | Comments? (0)

Leave a comment